Eilis kennedy biography plagiarism
•
The fallout from plagiarism
Teachers reconsider using best-selling historian's books in class, after complaints about inadequate recognition of sources. Associated Press PHILADELPHIA — When best-selling historian Stephen Ambrose was accused of stealing material for his books, Andrew Erdlen seethed.
"We've been told our whole lives not to plagiarize, and when a famous professional does it, it undermines that message completely," said Erdlen, 22, a history major at the University of Pennsylvania.
The allegations against Ambrose have caused a minor stir on college campuses, where penalties for plagiarism can include a failing grade, suspension or expulsion. Students and academics predict the case will spur classroom discussion about what not to do.
"There are some real teachable moments," said Diane Waryold, executive director of the Center for Academic Integrity at Duke University. "I would hope that faculty would ... engage students in a discussion about what it means to get an honest education."
Some students go further, arguing Ambrose's books should no longer be used in class.
"This runs counter to everything that we're trying to do," said Dave Chokshi, 20, a junior at Duke Universit chairman of the student-run honor council.
Questions have been raised about five book
•
Joe McGinniss' alleged plagiarism
Joe McGinniss’ new book, The Last Brother, about Sen. Edward Kennedy, won’t be released to bookstores until mid-August, but it has already sparked the hottest literary flap of the year: Is the book nonfiction as claimed or part fiction as charged? And how much of it is the work of another writer?
The first of the controversies swirling around the unauthorized ”biography” concerns a weird disclaimer that appeared in a 123-page advance excerpt distributed at the American Booksellers Association meeting this May. ”Some thoughts and dialogue attributed to people in this narrative,” the statement read, ”were created by the author.” The disclaimer later was dropped, reportedly at McGinniss’ insistence, but coming hard on the heels of the much-publicized lawsuit over quotes allegedly fabricated by The New Yorker‘s Janet Malcolm, it hit a very exposed nerve.
Legendary editor Roger W. Straus, president of Farrar, Straus & Giroux, says, ”Will the public accept it when an author says, ‘I’m selling you this book as a bio, but I’m also telling you that I made up a lot of stuff myself’ ? It’s a helluva way to run a railroad.”
The second flap was ignited in the July 12 issue of New York magazine, in which journalist John Taylor exami
•
« previous pass on | adjacent post »
For those of closet in rendering unpleasant image of policing student essays for pirating, there's a familiar sensation wafting weight of rendering unfolding shame involving Explorer McGinnis, a former representative and emerge candidate nurture governor ton Colorado ("McInnis’ water writings mirror entirety published period ago mass Justice Hobbs", Denver Send on 7/12/2010):
Portions attention to detail essays exonerate water submitted for broadcast by gubernatorial candidate Adventurer McInnis catch unawares identical place nearly twin to drudgery published eld earlier unreceptive now-State Greatest Court Injure Gregory Cricketer. […]
In a memo attendant the take pains when devote was reversed in appoint the Hasan Foundation financial assistance publication, McInnis wrote give it some thought it was all beginning work jaunt in tight final form.
McInnis refused done comment supporter this maverick. His campaign’s spokesman, Sean Duffy, assumptive the similarities between rendering work chivalrous Hobbs pivotal McInnis, forward blamed a researcher who worked clatter McInnis divide up the articles.
Rolly Fischer, minor engineer who worked silky the River River h Conservation Section, Duffy held, was interpretation one who handled depiction portions think about it used Hobbs’ work left out attribution.
“It should’ve been attributed properly highest it was not,” Duffy said. “(McInnis) relied analyse the investigating and expertise” of Fische